Best Etsy App for Shopify Comparison

Overview

The phrase best etsy app for shopify captures a common search by Shopify merchants who sell on Etsy or want to expand to Etsy. This guide compares the leading Etsy-Shopify integration apps, the decisions that matter, and which apps suit specific business needs.

What we compare: four real, widely used integrations for linking Shopify and Etsy: CedCommerce Etsy Integration, LitCommerce multi-channel sync, Etsify product importer and sync, and ExportFeed Etsy integration. Key decision criteria include inventory and order sync accuracy, support for variations and custom listings, multi-store and multi-channel capabilities, automation of price and inventory rules, fees and commissions, and customer support responsiveness.

Quick summary: CedCommerce is a feature-rich option for larger catalogs and merchants who want deep automation; LitCommerce is a balanced multi-channel manager for growing brands that need other marketplaces; Etsify is lightweight and inexpensive for sellers who mainly need product import and one-way sync; ExportFeed suits merchants who need flexible feed-based control and rule-based mapping. Pick CedCommerce for complex inventory and automation, LitCommerce for multi-marketplace scaling, Etsify for low-cost migrations and simple sync, and ExportFeed for feed rules and custom field control.

Best Etsy App for Shopify Top Picks

Cedcommerce Etsy Integration

Overview and Positioning

CedCommerce Etsy Integration is positioned as a full-featured connector aimed at merchants with medium to large product catalogs who need two-way sync between Shopify and Etsy. It focuses on automating listings, syncing inventory and orders, and handling Etsy-specific attributes like materials, tags, and variations.

Key Features and Strengths

• Two-way inventory and order sync so stock changes reflect across platforms.
• Support for variations, SKU mapping, and Etsy-specific attributes (tags, materials, processing time).
• Bulk listing and bulk edit tools for faster onboarding of catalogs.
• Automated order import to Shopify with order status mapping and shipment updates.
• Rule-based mapping for categories, pricing adjustments, and shipping profiles.

Limitations and Tradeoffs

• More advanced features require higher-tier plans or one-time setup fees in some cases.
• The UI can be more complex compared with lightweight importers, so there is a learning curve.
• Some Etsy attributes are manual to map if your Shopify data model is very different.

Pricing and Value

• Typical starting price: $29 per month for basic plan (as of June 2024).
• Mid-tier plans: commonly $59 to $99 per month with more SKUs, automation rules, and priority support.
• Enterprise or custom plans: custom pricing for large catalogs and additional services.
• Note: CedCommerce sometimes charges onboarding or customization fees for complex setups.

Best For

Merchants with 200+ SKUs, sellers who need robust two-way syncing and automation, and brands that plan to manage Etsy alongside other channels with complex mapping needs.

Litcommerce Multi-Channel Sync

Overview and Positioning

LitCommerce is a multi-channel integration platform that connects Shopify with various marketplaces including Etsy, Amazon, eBay, and Walmart. It targets growing brands that want consistent product and order management across multiple marketplaces, not just Etsy.

Key Features and Strengths

• Centralized product catalog management across Shopify and multiple marketplaces.
• Two-way sync for inventory and orders with centralized dashboard.
• Support for bulk listing, templated product attributes, and category mapping.
• Pricing rules and automated repricing for marketplace listings.
• Multiple store support (connect more than one Shopify store in higher tiers).

Limitations and Tradeoffs

• Because it is multi-channel, some Etsy-specific attributes may be generalized and require extra mapping steps.
• Advanced repricing and rules may be limited to higher-priced plans.
• Support response times vary by plan level; priority support usually reserved for upper tiers.

Pricing and Value

• Starter plans typically begin at $29 per month (as of June 2024) for a limited number of SKUs and orders.
• Growth plans: $59 to $99 per month for larger SKU allowances and more automation features.
• Professional and enterprise tiers: $149+ per month with higher quotas and dedicated onboarding.
• LitCommerce often bills by SKU or active listings cap, so monitor SKU counts to avoid sudden cost jumps.

Best For

Shopify merchants who plan to sell on multiple marketplaces (Etsy plus others), businesses that need centralized marketplace management, and sellers who want to scale across channels with a single interface.

Etsify Product Importer and Sync

Overview and Positioning

Etsify is a simpler, budget-friendly tool focused on importing Etsy listings into Shopify and offering basic sync capabilities. It is built for sellers who want a quick way to migrate listings or maintain a one-way feed from Etsy to Shopify without full multi-channel management.

Key Features and Strengths

• Fast import of Etsy listings including images, descriptions, and variations.
• Simple SKU and title mapping to Shopify.
• Lightweight sync options for inventory and orders (typically one-way or limited two-way).
• Lower-cost entry point and simpler UI for non-technical users.

Limitations and Tradeoffs

• Limited two-way sync functionality compared with full-featured integrators.
• Fewer automation options for pricing rules, shipping profile mapping, or complex variations.
• Not ideal for merchants who require high-volume automation or multi-marketplace support.

Pricing and Value

• Typical starting price: $9 per month for basic import features (as of June 2024).
• Mid-level plans: around $19 to $29 per month for more listings and sync frequency.
• Some plans may charge per import or have limits on the number of SKUs that can be synced.

Best For

Small shops migrating from Etsy to Shopify, sellers with under 200 SKUs who only need simple import and basic sync, and entrepreneurs on tight budgets looking to consolidate product data.

Exportfeed Etsy Integration

Overview and Positioning

ExportFeed is a feed-based integration tool that helps merchants publish and sync product feeds to marketplaces including Etsy. It emphasizes rule-based feed customization, flexible field mapping, and control over attributes, making it good for merchants who need granular control over listing data.

Key Features and Strengths

• Feed builder with field-level mapping and transformation rules (for titles, descriptions, tags).
• Scheduled feed updates to push inventory and listing changes.
• Support for custom attributes and complex mapping logic to meet Etsy requirements.
• Good for sellers who use custom Shopify fields or apps and need those mapped to Etsy fields.

Limitations and Tradeoffs

• Feed-based approach may mean near-real-time inventory sync is less precise than dedicated two-way apps.
• More technical setup for mapping rules versus out-of-the-box integrators.
• Pricing varies by feed count and update frequency.

Pricing and Value

• Starter plans often begin at $19 per month (as of June 2024) with limits on feeds and listings.
• Mid plans: $39 to $79 per month for more feeds and daily scheduled updates.
• Enterprise: custom pricing for high-frequency updates and larger catalogs.

Best For

Sellers who need precise control over how Shopify product fields map to Etsy attributes, brands with custom fields and complex data models, and merchants who care about feed-level transformations more than instant two-way sync.

How to Choose

Decision checklist

1. Catalog size and complexity - If you have 200+ SKUs, need multi-variation support, or use many custom attributes, favor CedCommerce or LitCommerce. For under 200 SKUs and simpler catalogs, Etsify or ExportFeed can be sufficient.
2. Sync direction and frequency - Need real-time two-way inventory and order sync? Choose CedCommerce or LitCommerce. One-way imports or scheduled feeds? Etsify and ExportFeed fit better.
3. Multi-channel ambitions - Planning to expand to Amazon, eBay, or Walmart as well? LitCommerce is purpose-built for multi-channel management; CedCommerce also supports multiple channels.
4. Control vs simplicity - Want granular field mapping and transformation rules? ExportFeed wins. Want simple onboarding and fast imports? Etsify is preferable.
5. Budget and support needs - Low monthly budget and minimal features: Etsify. Mid-range with decent automation: LitCommerce. Full automation, priority support, and enterprise features: CedCommerce.

Use this checklist to filter options by must-have features, then trial the top candidate for 7-14 days to validate SKU behavior, order flows, and pricing under your actual volume.

Quick Comparison

Feature | CedCommerce | LitCommerce | Etsify | ExportFeed — | —: | —: | —: | —: Starting price (approx) | $29 /mo | $29 /mo | $9 /mo | $19 /mo Two-way inventory sync | Yes | Yes | Limited | Scheduled feed (near real-time depends on plan) Order import to Shopify | Yes | Yes | Basic | Depends on feed setup Bulk listing tools | Strong | Strong | Basic | Moderate (feed-based) Custom field mapping | Good | Good | Limited | Excellent Best for | Large catalogs and automation | Multi-channel sellers | Small shops and migrations | Feed-level control and mapping

Quick pricing breakdown (typical tiers as of June 2024)

• CedCommerce: $29 /mo basic, $59 - $99 /mo mid-tier, custom enterprise pricing.
• LitCommerce: $29 /mo starter, $59 - $99 /mo growth, $149+ /mo enterprise.
• Etsify: $9 /mo basic, $19 - $29 /mo for more listings and sync frequency.
• ExportFeed: $19 /mo starter, $39 - $79 /mo mid, custom for enterprise.

Decision snapshot

Feature | CedCommerce | LitCommerce — | —: | —: Pricing | $29+/mo | $29+/mo Best for | Complex catalogs, automation | Multi-marketplace growth

FAQ

Do These Apps Support Two-Way Inventory Sync Between Etsy and Shopify?

Yes for CedCommerce and LitCommerce: they offer two-way inventory and order sync so stock changes on one platform update the other. Etsify typically provides one-way import or limited sync, and ExportFeed uses scheduled feeds which can approximate two-way behavior but may not be real-time.

Will Listings Created on Shopify Preserve All Etsy-Specific Attributes?

Not always. Shopify and Etsy use different attribute models. CedCommerce and LitCommerce do a better job mapping Etsy-specific fields (materials, tags, processing times) but you will often need to configure mapping rules.

ExportFeed gives the most granular control for field-level transformations.

How Much Setup Time Should I Expect?

Small shops using Etsify can import listings in a few hours. For CedCommerce or LitCommerce, expect one to several business days for mapping, testing, and onboarding for mid-sized catalogs. Complex catalogs or enterprise setups may require vendor-assisted onboarding over a week or more.

Are There Transaction or Commission Fees From the Apps?

Most apps charge a subscription fee rather than per-transaction commissions. Some integrators or marketplaces may offer commission-based pricing in specific markets, but the standard model for these four apps is monthly subscription tiers; always confirm billing terms and any usage overage fees.

Can I Run Multiple Shopify Stores with the Same App?

LitCommerce often supports multiple Shopify stores on higher tiers, and CedCommerce may offer multi-store support depending on plan. Etsify and ExportFeed may be limited to single-store setups or require separate subscriptions per store. Check plan details before onboarding multiple stores.

What About Syncing Orders and Shipping Details Back to Etsy?

CedCommerce and LitCommerce support importing Etsy orders to Shopify and updating shipping/fulfillment statuses back to Etsy. ExportFeed’s feed-based model can handle shipment updates if configured, while Etsify may offer more limited order sync capabilities. Validate the order flow during a free trial.

Further Reading

• Best Shopify Etsy Integration App Guide
• Best Shopify Marketplace App Guide
• Best Shopify Ebay Integration App for Sellers
• Top 20 Shopify Apps for Store Growth